News Page

Main Content

Thunderbolts*’ big depression metaphor hit me hard, because of what it’s missing most

Polygon's profile
Polygon
4h ago
Thunderbolts*’ big depression metaphor hit me hard, because of what it’s missing most

Context:

Marvel's Thunderbolts uses a superhero narrative to explore depression, focusing on characters like Yelena Belova and Bob, who struggle with feelings of emptiness and self-worth. The film portrays depression through the character Bob, whose inner turmoil manifests externally as a destructive force called the Void. The story critiques the simplistic resolution of mental health crises through actions like a group hug, rather than delving into the complexities of real-life struggles. While the film attempts to offer positive messages about mental health, it falls short by failing to address the shame and complexity involved in seeking help. The narrative concludes with a sense of discomfort, as Bob's obliviousness to the impact of his actions on his friends undermines the film's intended message of communal support and healing.

Dive Deeper:

  • Thunderbolts presents depression through Yelena Belova's reflections on her inability to connect with life, illustrating self-medication and emotional suppression as coping mechanisms. Her journey involves recognizing and confronting her own hopelessness while trying to help others like Bob, an experimental subject with similar struggles.

  • Bob's depression is depicted as the Void, a force that blankets Manhattan in darkness and whispers self-defeating messages, embodying the internal voice many with depression recognize. The film's climax critiques the notion that physical confrontation can resolve mental health issues, highlighting the need for emotional support instead.

  • The resolution of Bob's storyline through a group hug and reassurances from his friends is viewed as an oversimplified solution, lacking the complexity and shame often associated with real-life help-seeking behaviors. This portrayal raises concerns about the film's approach to depicting mental health recovery.

  • Bob's lack of awareness and gratitude for the help he receives, coupled with the comedic treatment of his condition, presents a problematic view of depression as a selfish and oblivious state, contrasting with the film's messages of empathy and support.

  • The narrative suggests that while the team learns to support each other, Bob remains a burden without self-awareness or contribution, challenging the idea that communal care is a straightforward remedy. His character highlights the ongoing challenges of mental health recovery and the need for personal accountability.

  • The film's portrayal of mental health struggles as a battle against evil forces simplifies the complex reality of depression, failing to provide a meaningful role for Bob in his recovery. This depiction risks trivializing the efforts required to navigate and overcome such challenges.

  • Despite its shortcomings, Thunderbolts offers a reminder that connection and shared experiences can disrupt depressive cycles, though the film's execution leaves room for deeper exploration of the nuanced realities of mental health crises.

Latest Entertainment

Related Stories