Upended by Meth, Some Communities Are Paying Users to Quit
Context:
Communities are increasingly using contingency management (CM) programs to combat meth addiction, as there is no medication to suppress cravings for stimulants like methamphetamine. These programs offer financial incentives to individuals who remain drug-free, with rewards increasing over time to encourage continued abstinence. Despite initial skepticism due to its transactional nature, research has shown that CM is more effective in treating stimulant addiction than traditional therapy methods. The approach has been supported by various sectors, including the Department of Veterans Affairs and private employers, though concerns about sustainability under certain political administrations persist. While CM has proven effective for many, issues such as potential misuse of incentives and the ongoing challenge of securing funding for these programs remain significant hurdles.
Dive Deeper:
Meth addiction presents a unique challenge in the national drug crisis due to the absence of medication to curb cravings, unlike opioids. As a result, clinics are turning to a strategy known as contingency management, which financially rewards individuals for negative drug tests.
The CM approach has shown better outcomes for stimulant addiction compared to counseling, with studies indicating that about half of the patients remain stimulant-free a year after completing the program. The rewards structure encourages positive behavior through incremental incentives.
Adoption of CM has been limited historically due to its transactional nature, but increasing evidence of its efficacy is changing perceptions. The Department of Veterans Affairs has utilized CM since 2011, and the Biden administration expanded federal support for these programs during the pandemic.
The growth of CM programs is rapid, with over 600 sites nationwide, and new technologies like telehealth apps are facilitating broader access, especially in rural areas. However, sustainability concerns persist, particularly with potential policy shifts under different administrations.
Challenges remain in ensuring the integrity of CM programs, as some participants may attempt to game the system by substituting urine samples or misusing rewards. Efforts to mitigate these issues include technological solutions and alternative testing methods.
Financial constraints are a significant barrier, as Medicaid's coverage for CM is limited, and programs often cap rewards to avoid tax implications. Nevertheless, some states have successfully lobbied for increased federal grant caps to support these initiatives.
Despite the obstacles, individuals like Jamie Mains have found success in CM programs, transitioning to sober living and involvement in community activities, indicating the potential for CM to facilitate long-term recovery and personal transformation.