News Page

Main Content

Dominik Szoboszlai red card: Did ref and VAR in Liverpool v Man City get Haaland drama right?

BBC News's profile
Original Story by BBC News
February 8, 2026
Dominik Szoboszlai red card: Did ref and VAR in Liverpool v Man City get Haaland drama right?

Context:

In a thrilling Premier League clash, Manchester City secured a 2-1 victory over Liverpool, but a late goal was disallowed due to a VAR review that identified a foul committed just before the ball crossed the line. The incident, involving a foul by both Dominik Szoboszlai and Erling Haaland, sparked controversy among fans and pundits, with opinions divided on the fairness of the decision. While some, like Gary Neville, lamented the loss of a dramatic moment, others, including Roy Keane, saw it as adding to the game's excitement. Looking ahead, the implications of this ruling could be significant for both teams in the title race, illustrating the ongoing challenges of balancing the spirit of the game with strict adherence to the rules.

Dive Deeper:

  • The disallowed goal occurred in the final moments of the match, with Alisson out of position as Liverpool attempted to equalize. Haaland, chasing the ball, was initially obstructed by Szoboszlai, leading to a foul that the referee recognized despite playing an advantage.

  • VAR referee John Brooks intervened after Haaland's subsequent foul on Szoboszlai, which prevented the latter from clearing the ball off the line. This sequence of events highlighted the complexities surrounding fouls in quick succession.

  • Referee Craig Pawson's decision to disallow the goal was based on the interpretation that Szoboszlai would likely have stopped the ball had he not been fouled, leading to his potential dismissal for denying an obvious goal-scoring opportunity.

  • Former players expressed mixed reactions; Gary Neville criticized the VAR decision as unjust and detrimental to the game's enjoyment, while Roy Keane argued it enhanced the drama of the match.

  • Haaland expressed sympathy for Szoboszlai, suggesting that a goal should have been allowed instead of enforcing a red card. Manchester City’s coach Pep Guardiola echoed a similar sentiment, urging the referee to let the goal stand.

  • The controversy surrounding the VAR decision reflects ongoing debates within football about the balance between upholding rules and preserving the excitement of key moments in matches.

  • The outcome of this match and the VAR decision may have long-term implications for both teams as they vie for the Premier League title, with each point potentially proving crucial as the season progresses.

Latest News

Related Stories