News Page

Main Content

Etsy faces backlash over including AI model training in new policy update

CBC News's profile
Original Story by CBC News
November 21, 2026
Etsy faces backlash over including AI model training in new policy update

Context:

A policy update from Etsy that allows using sellers’ content to train AI drew sharp backlash in Canada, with many creators pulling products from the platform. Sellers describe the change as a threat to their livelihood and autonomy over their work, prompting calls for greater communication and reconsideration of terms. Etsy asserts that creators retain ownership and that the company will discuss the policy to clarify intent, while acknowledging room for improvement in outreach. The dispute highlights tensions between AI-driven business models and independent artisans, with potential impacts on listings, income, and future platform participation. A path forward involves policy clarifications and ongoing dialogue with affected sellers.

Dive Deeper:

  • Tsuki Matsuba, a Vancouver-based seller, began removing her custom stationery from Etsy in response to the upcoming AI policy rollout on December 16, fearing content could be used to train AI systems.

  • The policy update explicitly states that Etsy, its third-party partners, and vendors may use sellers’ content to develop, train, test, and improve artificial intelligence and machine learning technologies.

  • Matsuba described the change as a 'kick in the teeth' and attributed part of her job loss in animation to AI, signaling deep concerns about being forced to choose between income and permitting AI training on her work.

  • Other Canadian creators, including Tina Nawrocki of Ottawa and The Calendork of Halifax, announced they would close or remove their Etsy shops to avoid AI-related use of their artwork.

  • Etsy’s head of customer operations, James Ossman, defended the company by saying sellers’ creative work belongs to them and that the firm does not intend to copy or replace their originality with AI, while promising further discussion to clarify the terms.

  • The company acknowledged that it should have communicated changes more effectively and said it will continue conversations with sellers to clarify intentions and usage of content under the updated terms.

  • The broader reaction situates the policy change within a climate where AI investments are seen as providing competitive advantages, underscoring tensions between platform policies and independent creators' livelihoods.

Latest News

Related Stories