Judge Blocks Trump's New Student Loan Restrictions
Context:
A federal judge blocked the Biden-era rule that would lower federal student-loan caps for graduate programs in nursing and other healthcare fields, leaving professional-degree borrowing capped at up to $50,000 per year and $200,000 total. U.S. District Judge Beryl Howell sided with eight trade groups that argued the Education Department overstepped, delaying the rule set to take effect July 1. The decision hinges on Congress’s 2025 law, which had altered loan definitions; Howell said the department must adhere to the longstanding definition in place when the law was enacted, triggering invalidation under the Administrative Procedure Act. The Education Department is reviewing the ruling and will decide on next steps, while the ruling preserves existing borrowing paths for now.
Dive Deeper:
Eight trade organizations, including the American Association of Nurse Practitioners and PA Education Association, challenged the Education Department's May 1 rule outlining new caps linked to the 2025 law passed by a Republican-led Congress.
Judge Beryl Howell ruled late Wednesday that the department cannot implement the new caps because Congress explicitly adopted a preexisting regulatory definition of 'professional degree' when enacting the law, limiting the department's discretionary power.
Under the 2025 framework, professional-degree borrowing is limited to up to $50,000 per year and $200,000 total, while other graduate programs face lower annual and aggregate caps; the rule redefined which degrees fall into those categories.
Howell declined to extend the injunction to halt all uncapped borrowing pending a new rule, stating she could not address the core frustration with Congress’s move to eliminate uncapped borrowing, and instead kept the status quo until a more complete remedy is issued.
The Education Department indicated it is reviewing the decision and will take appropriate action, effectively pausing the intended July 1 implementation pending further steps.