News Page

Main Content

U.S. Court Agrees to Keep Trump Tariffs Intact as Appeal Gets Underway

The New York Times's profile
Original Story by The New York Times
June 11, 2025
U.S. Court Agrees to Keep Trump Tariffs Intact as Appeal Gets Underway

Context:

A federal appeals court has temporarily upheld President Trump's tariffs on China and other trading partners, providing an interim victory for the administration despite prior rulings deeming them illegal. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit's decision enables the continuation of Trump's economic strategy, which utilizes the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) to impose tariffs without congressional approval. This ruling follows a recent agreement between the U.S. and China to extend a trade truce, which could have been jeopardized without the court's stay. Legal challenges persist as small businesses and states have sued, claiming financial harm and arguing that Trump's use of the IEEPA exceeds its intended scope. The administration remains prepared to defend the tariffs up to the Supreme Court, maintaining that they are essential for reshaping global trade and supporting domestic manufacturing.

Dive Deeper:

  • The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit agreed to let Trump's tariffs remain, granting a temporary victory while the legality of these tariffs is debated in court. This decision is crucial for maintaining the Trump administration's global trade negotiations, which might have been disrupted if the tariffs were lifted.

  • Trump's use of the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) to impose tariffs is unprecedented, as it sidesteps Congress and aims to reorient global trade by imposing significant taxes on imports. The administration argues this strategy is necessary for economic restructuring and gaining advantageous trade deals.

  • The legal challenges stem from claims by small businesses and states that the tariffs are illegal and financially damaging. A trade court had previously ruled that Trump's actions exceeded the powers granted by the IEEPA, ordering the tariffs to be halted.

  • The appeals court's decision to extend the stay keeps the tariffs in place while further legal deliberations occur, highlighting the contentious nature of the president's claimed trade powers under the IEEPA.

  • Negotiators from the U.S. and China have recently agreed to a framework aimed at extending their trade truce, a move that could have been compromised if the appeals court had not upheld the tariffs temporarily.

  • Jeffrey Schwab, representing small businesses, expressed disappointment at the court's temporary allowance of the tariffs, asserting that the IEEPA does not permit the president to impose arbitrary taxes. He remains hopeful that the courts will ultimately rule against the tariffs.

  • The Trump administration is prepared to defend the tariffs to the Supreme Court if necessary, emphasizing their role in reshaping global economic policies and bolstering U.S. domestic industries.

Latest News

Related Stories