News Page

Main Content

Former Commanders trade was a major mistake for Washington

Sports Illustrated's profile
Original Story by Sports Illustrated
December 25, 2025
Former Commanders trade was a major mistake for Washington

Context:

The trade of left tackle Trent Williams by the Washington Commanders to the San Francisco 49ers in 2020 continues to haunt the franchise, reflecting poor organizational decisions made by the previous regime. Williams, who sat out the entire 2019 season due to a dispute with the team, has since achieved significant accolades, including his 12th Pro Bowl selection this season. Meanwhile, while Washington acquired Laremy Tunsil to bolster their offensive line, his impressive pass-blocking performance has gone largely unrecognized, as he was not selected for the Pro Bowl. The lingering effects of the Williams trade highlight the importance of sound roster management, especially as new leadership aims to learn from past mistakes. Moving forward, the Commanders hope to avoid losing key players and make more strategic decisions.

Dive Deeper:

  • Trent Williams was traded to the San Francisco 49ers for a fifth-round pick in 2020 and a third-round pick for 2021 after a year-long dispute that kept him off the field in 2019. Washington used these picks to select Keith Ismael and Benjamin St. Juste.

  • Laremy Tunsil, acquired from the Houston Texans, has started almost every game since joining Washington and achieved an 88.9 pass-blocking grade from Pro Football Focus, ranking second among NFL tackles.

  • Despite Tunsil's high performance, he was not selected for the Pro Bowl, which has caused frustration among fans and analysts given his contribution to the team.

  • From 2021 to 2023, Williams made four consecutive Pro Bowl selections and received three All-Pro honors, demonstrating his elite status in the league.

  • This season, Williams became just the fourth player in NFL history to reach 12 Pro Bowl selections, joining legends like Bruce Matthews and Will Shields.

  • The Commanders are currently under the leadership of Adam Peters and Dan Quinn, who are expected to make more informed decisions to prevent further roster missteps.

  • As the team progresses, there is a focus on ensuring that valuable players are retained to build a more competitive roster and avoid regretful trades like that of Williams.

Latest Sports

Related Stories