Red Sox Trevor Story breaks silence on being replaced by Marcelo Mayer
Context:
The Boston Red Sox are considering bringing top prospect Marcelo Mayer onto their big-league roster as veteran shortstop Trevor Story struggles with performance and injuries. Story, who has not been able to play 100 games in a season since joining the Red Sox in 2022, has seen a decline in his performance, evidenced by a batting average of .252 in 2025. Despite his past accolades with the Colorado Rockies, injuries have hindered his career in Boston, prompting questions about his future with the team. Story expressed a positive attitude towards the potential change, recognizing Mayer's talent and the strategic decisions of the front office. Meanwhile, fans are eager to see Mayer, a standout in the organization's prospect pool, step into a significant role to potentially enhance the team's performance and playoff chances.
Dive Deeper:
Trevor Story's tenure with the Boston Red Sox has been marred by injuries, limiting his game appearances and affecting his performance since his signing in 2022.
Story's performance in the 2025 season includes a batting slash line of .252/.291/.371, along with 45 strikeouts and 36 hits, reflecting his struggle to regain the form that earned him two All-Star nods with the Colorado Rockies.
The Red Sox organization is considering Marcelo Mayer, a highly-touted prospect, as a potential replacement for Story, given his struggles and the team's desire to improve their playoff prospects.
Story maintains a positive outlook on the possibility of being replaced by Mayer, acknowledging the young player's talent and the necessity of strategic team decisions by the front office.
Fans are eager to see Mayer, part of the organization's 'big three' prospects, join the major league roster in hopes of bolstering the team's performance and success.
The Red Sox, meanwhile, have been actively making roster changes, including adjustments to their pitching staff and lineup, to enhance their competitiveness.
Peter Chawaga, an experienced journalist, has covered Major League Baseball extensively, providing insights into player performances and team strategies in various publications.
The Boston Red Sox haven’t been shy about making changes as they seek a return to the playoffs.
This past offseason, the team shook up its pitching staff, replacing Nick Pivetta and James Paxton with Walker Buehler and Garrett Crochet. It swapped Aroldis Chapman into the bullpen for Kenley Jansen. And it pushed Rafael Devers into a designated hitter role to make room for Alex Bregman.
And now, as a veteran shortstop Trevor Story struggles, the Red Sox could be eyeing a top prospect replacement in Marcelo Mayer.
“Story is 32 and has missed far more games than he has played since signing with the Red Sox before the 2022 season,” as Peter Abraham wrote for The Boston Globe. “Injuries changed the course of his career and now it’s fair to wonder if the Sox would be a better team with Marcelo Mayer playing shortstop.”
After earning two All-Star nods and two Silver Slugger Awards in his time with the Colorado Rockies, Story has failed to recapture that success since joining the Red Sox in 2022. He has been unable to log 100 games in any season in Boston and has played in fewer than 50 in each of the past three years.
Story has had some good moments in 2025, but so far he’s slashing just .252/.291/.371 with 45 strikeouts and 36 hits.
Meanwhile, Mayer is a member of the organization’s “big three” of highly-touted prospects and fans are calling for him to get a look on the big-league roster. Of course, that would mean Story taking a backseat.
When asked about the idea of being replaced by Mayer, Story broke his silence on the idea with a positive outlook.
“It doesn’t bother me,” Story said, per Abraham. “I think Marcelo is a great player. It’s up to the front office to find ways to make it work. I’ve always said it’s never bad having too many good players.”
More MLB: Yankees DJ LeMahieu hit with unfortunate rehab setback