Context:

The Pittsburgh Steelers had initially set the stage for Aaron Rodgers by acquiring DK Metcalf to pair with George Pickens, forming a potent wide receiver duo, and adding running backs to support Jaylen Warren. However, the Steelers traded Pickens to the Dallas Cowboys for future draft picks, which sparked speculation about Rodgers' retirement, as the team could lack the competitive edge necessary to entice him. With Rodgers coming off a 5-12 season due to an Achilles tear and turning 42 soon, the idea of retirement seems appealing, especially considering the physical demands of the AFC North. The Steelers' offensive lineup, without a clear secondary wide receiver, might not be attractive enough for Rodgers, raising doubts about his potential move to Pittsburgh. Although the Steelers need a quarterback like Rodgers, uncertainties remain about whether he will choose to continue his career or retire peacefully, with the latter option seeming more viable given the circumstances.

Dive Deeper:

• The Pittsburgh Steelers initially created a favorable environment for Aaron Rodgers by acquiring DK Metcalf, forming a strong receiving pair with George Pickens, and adding depth to their running back position to support Jaylen Warren, aiming to attract Rodgers as a free agent.

• The Steelers' decision to trade George Pickens to the Dallas Cowboys for future draft picks has raised questions about the competitiveness of their offensive lineup and its potential impact on Aaron Rodgers' decision to join or retire.

• Speculation about Rodgers' retirement intensified following the trade, given his recent struggles with injuries, notably a torn Achilles that led to a 5-12 record with the New York Jets, and his approaching 42nd birthday, making retirement a comfortable option.

• The AFC North's reputation as the most physically demanding division adds to the uncertainty, as Rodgers, already considered a Hall of Famer, might prefer to retire rather than risk ending his career on a low note with a potentially weak Steelers offense.

• Despite the Steelers' need for a skilled quarterback, the lack of a clear secondary wide receiver post-Pickens trade casts doubt on their ability to attract Rodgers, leaving his future plans uncertain amidst the rumors and speculation.

• The Pittsburgh Steelers appeared to have stacked the deck for Aaron Rodgers.

• They traded for DK Metcalf to create a two-headed WR monster with George Pickens. They added a couple of running backs to join Jaylen Warren. This was a setup for Rodgers to succeed after signing a free agent contract.

• Except the Steelers traded Pickens to the Dallas Cowboys on Wednesday for two future draft picks.

• Those future picks aren't doing Rodgers any good.

• MORE: The real reason the Steelers traded George Pickens to the Cowboys

• Social media was quick to speculate: What if Rodgers decides to retire?

• With or without Pickens why would Aaron Rodgers come back to the nfl? Especially the afc north? They stand no chance at winning anything important and he’s going to get beat up in the most physical division of football for 17 weeks then retire looking like this guy pic.twitter.com/BrqBzfNl9E

• — ham nachos (@HerpCurbstreet) May 7, 2025

  If I'm Aaron Rodgers, I'd rather just retire than try to end my career on a better note with a likely bad Steelers offense. He's a Hall of Famer no matter what, but is a shell of his former self and not gong to elevate anyone to a deep playoff run. Just retire and enjoy life.

• — Mike J. Asti (@MikeAsti11) May 7, 2025 That's just a small sampling.

• Reports earlier in the offseason indicated retirement was legitimately on the table for Rodgers, who will turn 42 in December.

• MORE: Steelers planned to draft Shedeur Sanders in specific round

• He's coming off a 5-12 season as the Jets starter after tearing his Achilles four plays in to the 2023 season.

• Retirement would be a comfortable option, whereas joining the Steelers could be more filled with adversity.

• MORE: Cowboys facing a $100 million George Pickens question

• Rodgers probably doesn't want to go out with that 5-12 record, but who knows? It's best not to guess what he's going to do.

• The Steelers still need him, but does Rodgers need a receiving corps without a clear WR2? Maybe he won't be coming to town after all.

• MORE NFL NEWS:

• • Shedeur Sanders' chances of being traded get key update
  • T.J. Watt contract extension just got a lot easier
  • How Eagles GM pursued new QB
  • Mike Evans' retirement insurance plan in place at WR
  • Trey Hendrickson gets a concerning holdout update
  • Packers' Jaire Alexander trade rumors might be done